ECB President Christine Lagarde Affirmed That Rates Need To Go Significantly Higher
Aa
Share
The Franklin Templeton Fixed Income (FTFI) Central Bank Watch is a qualitative assessment of the central banks for the Group of Ten (G10) nations plus two additional countries (China and South Korea). See full methodology on page 6.
Key highlights
Stepping down pace of hiking ≠ outright dovish pivot. A majority of developed market (DM) central banks should gradually reach their respective peak policy rates through the first half (H1) of 2023. The US Federal Reserve (Fed) and the European Central Bank (ECB) remain on the most hawkish end of the spectrum. The Bank of Korea (BoK) may well be the closest to a dovish pivot.
Tight labor markets and sticky inflation are still the primary concerns. Although headline inflation may be receding, central banks remain concerned about tight labor markets keeping wages elevated, which in turn can spill over into the stickier components of inflation.
Bank of Japan (BoJ) surprises with a policy tweak. A wider trading band for 10-year Japanese government bonds (JGBs) has already had implications for global bond markets and US dollar dominance. Although the BoJ insists its latest move isn’t a step toward broader tightening, a policy move in 2023 is very much on the table.
Latest thoughts on global central bank policy
Far from done on tightening policy; markets think otherwise
As expected, the Fed downshifted to a 50-basis point (bp) hike at the December Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) meeting. “Ongoing increases” in the policy rate were deemed to be appropriate— giving the Fed optionality in February. Despite recent downside surprises in inflation, the Fed raised its median inflation projections, prompting a higher median peak policy rate in 2023. Fed Chair Jerome Powell welcomed the deceleration in monthly core inflation but noted that services inflation excluding housing remains uncomfortably high. Meanwhile, in our view, the ongoing strength of the labor market and a still-elevated level of demand-supply imbalance will keep wage and services inflation well supported. Despite Powell’s hawkish rhetoric, markets continue to price in a peak rate of just 4.9, with rate cuts beginning in September 2023 and 50 bps of cumulative cuts by the end of the year. We, on the other hand, expect a total of 75 to 100 bps of increases, given the still-negative real policy rate and the likely persistence of services inflation. However, smaller (25 bp) hikes wouldn’t come as a surprise since the FOMC intends to “feel their way” to an appropriate policy stance. Once at the peak rate, the Fed will signal a pause through 2023 as it gauges the full economic impact from all the tightening.
Closing in on a pause?
After raising rates at a record pace of 400 bps over the past nine months to 4.25%, the BoC signaled a willingness to pause at its next policy meeting on January 25. The December statement was in sharp contrast to the one from October, when the bank was expecting rates to go even higher. However, the Bank did not firmly close the door on future rate hikes, placing the onus on the evolution of economic data to determine future action. The BoC noted that the economy continues to operate in excess demand, and that while sequential measures of core inflation may be losing momentum, they remain uncomfortably high. We believe the BoC’s adoption of a more neutral tone is meant to gauge how tighter monetary policy is working its way through the economy; it is not indicative of an outright dovish pivot. If inflation data were to surprise to the upside, we would not rule out a final 25-bp hike in January. While we expect the BoC to remain on pause throughout 2023, it faces a challenge in convincing markets not to expect a shift to cutting rates—especially as bond yields fall.
Smaller hikes = more tightening
The ECB raised its policy rates by 50 bps in December, slowing the pace from two consecutive 75-bp jumbo hikes. However, the message coming from the statement and press conference was extremely hawkish. ECB President Christine Lagarde affirmed that rates need to go significantly higher, at a steady pace (of 50 bps) and over a period of time. This effectively erases any dovish pivot expectations of a more careful calibration going forward, reinforced by explicitly pushing back against market pricing of a sub-3% terminal rate, and indicating that rates will remain in restrictive territory to dampen demand and inflation expectations. The balance sheet shrinkage will accelerate in 2023 with the beginning of passive quantitative tightening (QT) on its asset purchase program (APP), starting in March at a pace of EUR 15 billion per month (approximately half of expected redemptions) to be reviewed in June. Inflation is forecasted to remain above target until mid-2025, supported by higher wages, while a soft-landing scenario for growth looks increasingly optimistic over the medium-term. We now see the terminal rate at a minimum of 3.25% with upside risks linked to the inflation dynamics of the next two quarters.
Source: cbw-0123-u.pdf (widen.net)
